Brighton Heights Reformed Church Demolished

Staten Island's historic Brighton Heights Reformed Church (a designated New York City landmark) was demolished on June 29, 1996, after a fire the previous day. The fire was started by a worker removing paint with a heat gun. CLICK HERE for information on issues raised by the fire and demolition.

Brighton Heights Reformed Church

The Brighton Heights Reformed Church, 320 St. Mark's Place, at Fort Place on Staten Island was designed by architect John Correja and built in 1863. When the Reformed Protestant Dutch Church in Tompkinsville outgrew its original building, it acquired this property in nearby Brighton Heights and commissioned the Manhattan architect John Correja to design a stone structure. The cost of building the Gothic Revival design proved high, and Correja eventually adapted the form to allow-for the construction of a less expensive wooden building. With its prominent spire, the church was highly visible along the northeast shore of Staten Island. It was designated a City Landmark in 1967. More information about the church.

Remains of the Church
Church ablaze

More than just a historic landmark, the Brighton Heights Reformed Church led the effort on Staten Island to help the poor and needy. Project Hospitality (a not-for-profit group dedicated to assisting the homeless on Staten Island) was founded in the Brighton Heights Reformed Church and operated a food pantry for the poor out of the church.

The three-alarm fire destroyed the roof and heavily damaged the steeple of the 133-year old church. The fire began at about 3:30 p.m. and required upwards of 200 firefighters from Staten Island and Brooklyn to subdue it later that evening. Firefighters at first stood by helplessly because of a lack of water pressure. They eventually raised three cherry-pickers 80 feet into the air and blasted water at the building.

roof ablaze
Firemen at the scene The church, which was being repainted, had already suffered a small fire in November 1995, also started by a worker stripping paint off the exterior with a heat gun. Both fires were caused by workers hired by Sunrise Restorations of Stapleton on Staten Island.
Borough President Molinari
Staten Island Borough President Guy Molinari was instrumental in slowing the demolition process while preservationists salvaged some of the stained glass windows. In this picture the Borough President negotiates while Church Pastor Bob Schwander looks on.
Ken Lustbader

Ken Lustbader of the Landmarks Conservancy surveys a piece of salvaged window.

The Preservation League of Staten Island appropriated funds on June 30, 1996, to assist in salvaging the Church's stained glass windows.

CLICK HERE for information on issues raised by the fire and demolition.

Rubble after demolition

Color pictures by Linda Jones & David Jones
Page created by David Goldfarb and Linda Jones
For more information send e-mail to wha@panix.com
rev. 11/04/96